Detached vs. Attached ADUs in Colorado: Which is Right for You?

What Are Detached and Attached ADUs?

Detached ADUs

A detached ADU is a standalone structure separate from the primary residence. Often referred to as backyard cottages, granny flats, or tiny homes, these units provide a completely independent living space. Detached ADUs are popular for their privacy and flexibility, often allowing for unique architectural designs.

Attached ADUs

An attached ADU is physically connected to the main house, either as an extension, basement conversion, or garage conversion. These units share at least one wall with the primary home, making them more integrated while still functioning as separate living spaces.

Advantages of Detached ADUs

1. Flexible Use Cases

Detached ADUs are incredibly versatile and can serve various purposes over time. For example:

•  Ideal to transform the unit into a short-term rental for platforms like Airbnb.
• Use it as a home office or creative studio during specific life phases.
• Repurpose it later for family use or a guesthouse as your needs evolve. This adaptability ensures a long-term return on investment, no matter how your circumstances change.

2. Privacy and Independence

Detached ADUs provide a fully independent living space, ideal for:

• Rental tenants who prefer privacy.
• Family members who need separate accommodations, such as aging parents or adult children.
• Homeowners who want a standalone office or creative studio.

3. Design Flexibility

Because detached ADUs are standalone structures, they offer greater flexibility in:

• Architectural styles and layouts.
• Customizing features like skylights, patios, or unique rooflines.
• Maximizing views and natural light, particularly on larger lots.

4. Increased Property Value

A detached ADU can significantly boost your property’s value by adding a functional and attractive secondary dwelling. According to Zillow, homes with ADUs often sell for up to 35% more than homes without them.

5. Avoid Potential Complexities of Attached ADUs

One advantage of detached ADUs is that they eliminate the potential complexities associated with attached units. Detached ADUs don’t require integration with the existing home’s structure, avoiding challenges like retrofitting the existing home. This independence simplifies the design and construction process, ensuring fewer disruptions and a smoother project overall.

Advantages of Attached ADUs

1. Streamlined Construction Process

Attached ADUs often benefit from a streamlined construction process. Utilizing existing structures, such as basements or garages, can potentially reduce the need for new foundations and have less site work. 

2. Enhanced Accessibility

Attached ADUs offer enhanced accessibility due to their proximity to the main home. This makes them particularly appealing for multi-generational living, as they provide easier access for elderly family members or individuals with mobility challenges. Features like shared entrances or shorter walking distances between spaces make these units practical and convenient.

3. Efficient Use of Space

Attached ADUs are an excellent option for properties with limited yard space. By utilizing existing structures like basements or garages, you can create a functional ADU without sacrificing outdoor areas.

4. Easier Utility Connections

Since attached ADUs share a connection with the main house, utility setup can be simpler and less expensive. This includes water, sewer, electrical, and HVAC systems.

Challenges of Detached ADUs

1. Higher Costs

Detached ADUs typically involve:

• Constructing a new foundation.
• Extending utility lines.
• Can have increased material and labor expenses compared to attached units.

2. Zoning and Setback Requirements

Detached ADUs are subject to specific zoning regulations, such as:

• Minimum lot sizes.
• Setback distances from property lines.
• Height restrictions.

3. Larger Footprint

These units tend to require more space, which may not be feasible for smaller lots in urban areas.

Challenges of Attached ADUs

1. Limited Privacy

Because attached ADUs share walls with the main house, occupants may have less privacy compared to a detached unit. This can be a concern for renters or family members seeking independence.

2. Design Restrictions

Attached ADUs often need to match the architectural style of the main home, limiting design options.

3. Impact on Main Home

Adding an attached ADU may reduce available space in the primary residence or alter its layout, particularly with garage or basement conversions.

4. Potential Complications

Attached ADUs can potentially have complications when connecting to the primary residence.

Unique Benefits of Detached vs. Attached ADUs

Unique Benefits of Detached ADUs

• Enhanced Outdoor Living: Detached ADUs often provide opportunities to create unique outdoor spaces, such as private patios, gardens, or courtyards. This added feature enhances the overall living experience and increases property appeal.
• Infrastructure Autonomy: Detached units have all new materials and don't have the potential complexities of connecting to existing infrastructure. Additionally, you can have a more independent design from the primary residence.

Unique Benefits of Attached ADUs

• Structural Synergy: Attached ADUs integrate seamlessly with the existing home, leveraging its structure to simplify construction.
• Basement Transformations: Converting a basement into an ADU is an excellent way to repurpose underutilized space. This approach maintains the primary home’s footprint while creating a fully functional living area that can accommodate tenants, family members, or serve as a private retreat.
• Encourages Creative Design Solutions: Attached ADUs challenge homeowners and design teams to maximize functionality and style within existing constraints. This often leads to innovative layouts, multifunctional spaces, and clever use of materials that enhance both the ADU and the main home.

How to Choose Between Detached and Attached ADUs

1. Assess Your Goals

• Rental Income: Detached ADUs often command higher rental rates due to increased privacy.
• Family Use: Attached ADUs may be more practical for housing relatives who want proximity to the main home.
• Personal Use: Detached units are ideal for offices, studios, or guesthouses.

2. Evaluate Your Lot

• Lot Size: Larger lots are better suited for detached ADUs.
• Existing Structures: If your property has a garage or basement, converting it into an attached ADU may be more cost-effective.
• Zoning and Setbacks: Ensure your lot meets the necessary requirements for your chosen ADU type.

3. Consider Your Budget

• Initial Costs: Attached ADUs can be more affordable to build.
• Long-Term Value: Detached ADUs may offer a higher return on investment due to their versatility and rental appeal.

How Kindred Tiny Homes Can Help

Choosing between a detached or attached ADU can be overwhelming, but you don’t have to navigate the process alone. At Kindred Tiny Homes, we:

• Evaluate Your Property: Our team conducts comprehensive site assessments to determine the best ADU type for your lot.
• Analyze Cost-Benefit Ratios: We help you weigh the financial implications of detached vs. attached ADUs, ensuring you get the best value for your investment.
• Customize Your Design: Whether you’re building an attached or detached ADU, we tailor the design to fit your property’s unique characteristics and your personal vision.
• Streamline Permitting: We handle all the paperwork, ensuring compliance with Colorado’s zoning and building regulations.
• Optimize Utility Connections: Our experts plan efficient and cost-effective solutions for water, sewer, gas, and electrical systems.
• Deliver Quality Construction: With a commitment to craftsmanship and customer satisfaction, we bring your ADU vision to life.

Partnering with a reputable design-build firm like Kindred Tiny Homes ensures a stress-free experience and a high-quality outcome, regardless of the ADU type you choose.

Case Studies: Real-Life Examples

1. Detached ADU in Lone Tree

A family in Lone Tree wanted a private rental unit to generate passive income. Kindred Tiny Homes:

• Designed a detached ADU that complemented the existing home’s architecture.
• Integrated sustainable features like solar panels and energy-efficient appliances.
• Achieved full compliance with local zoning laws, ensuring a smooth approval process.

2. Attached ADU in Arvada

In Arvada, a homeowner needed a living space for aging parents. We:

• Converted their basement into a fully functional attached ADU.
• Installed accessibility features, including widened doorways and a walk-in shower.
• Delivered the project on time and within budget, enhancing the home’s functionality and value.

Which ADU Is Right for You?

Deciding between a detached and attached ADU depends on your goals, property characteristics, and budget. Both options offer unique benefits, and with the right planning, either can enhance your property’s value and functionality.

At Kindred Tiny Homes, we specialize in creating custom ADU solutions tailored to your needs. Whether you’re envisioning a private backyard retreat or a seamless extension of your home, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.

‍